I’ve been getting frustrated with Google Adsense lately and their poor payouts. I know Google isn’t the one paying me, it’s the publishers, but anyways I’ve been seriously contemplating making the switch to Yahoo Publisher Network this weekend. I would like to make the switch before the month is up, this way I have a full month to gage stats on and I won’t have any money sitting in my Google account. For those of you who don’t know, Google will not let you take money out until you reach $100.
I am on pace to make $70 this month from Adsense alone. I am curious if I can top that with YPN. In this post, I’ll go over some of the pros and cons of making the switch.
Pro #1 – More Money
Yahoo is known for having better payouts than Google. This might be because they are still in beta and have not gone international yet. But regardless, a higher payout is always better. I’ve heard of people getting $15-$35 clicks on Yahoo. If I had two of those I’d be set for the month!
Pro #2 – Money in the Account
I tried Yahoo sporadically when it was first launched months ago. I was able to accumulate about $18 in my account. It has just been sitting there, because like Google, you have to have at least $100 in your account to make a withdraw.
Pro #3 – Ad Targeting
During the early days of YPN all the ads were credit card and loan ads. Yahoo has since implemented ad targeting, enabling better targeted ads for your website. There are about 10 ad categories you can choose from, and Yahoo will only display ads from that category on your site. So if you run a gaming site you might actually get ads for games and toys. Yahoo has been working on better targeted ads, but they still don’t have half the clientele that Google does. The more publishers Yahoo signs up, the larger the ad base will be, giving you better targeted ads.
I can’t really think of any other positives for making the switch to YPN. Mostly, I just want more money. I am sick of getting only $3.00 for 25 clicks. I’m tired of seeing 1 click for $.02. To me it’s not worth it and feels like a slap in the face to put an ad on my page and only get 2 cents a click.
Now for some of the Cons…
Con #1 – Ad Targeting
I know I just talked about ad targeting as a positive, but it is also a negative. Yahoo is getting better now, but they still don’t come close to Google. For example, on my Sonic Wild Fire website, I see ads for Sonic games, Sonic the Hedgehog, or Nintendo Wii. Google does an excellent job in this department. If I place Yahoo ads on Sonic Wild Fire, I will probably see an ad or two for an arcade and maybe a board game company. I won’t see something for a Nintendo site and I definitely won’t see an ad for a different Sonic site.
Con #2 – No International Clicks Allowed
Since Yahoo Publisher Network is still in Beta, you are not allowed to have international visitors click on your ads. This will result in a banned account. I do have some international users, but I don’t think it is enough to warrant a ban. I really only get like 20+ clicks a day, and maybe like 3-4 are international. So with the drop to YPN, I may only get 1 international click a day. There are ways around this by using a method called geo-targeting. Using a script that finds a visitor’s IP address, you can alter the type of ad you choose to display depending on where the user lives. There are some holes in doing this, but it might be worth a try.
Con #3 – Less clicks
Because the ads aren’t targeted as well, the CTR (click through rate) will go down. Exact CTR isn’t allowed to be discussed, but I can say that it hovers around 3% for all my non forum sites combined. The CTR will probably drop, but hopefully the increase in payout will make up for it.
Con #4 - No Images by the ads
Google allows us to place images by the ads, assuming they are related and do not mislead the visitor to clicking on the ads. An example of this can be seen on Layout Pimps where I have a few user profile pictures in that very first section. Yahoo does not allow this at all. No images or graphics by the ads. What a bummer!
If I make the switch to YPN tonight, I will be sure to fill you in on the results of the move. I will give Yahoo at least a week of my time to test the waters. If I still hover around $2-3 a day then I will make the switch back to Google, simply because the ads look nicer on your website because they are related to your content. But If I can improve my daily earnings to $4-$5 or more a day, Yahoo is here to stay.
My goal is to reach $10/day from contextual ads alone by December 31. If making the move to YPN helps bring me closer to my goal, then I will say goodbye to Google forever.